2022 has already proven to be a particularly notable year for star-studded films. To take just one example, amsterdam is an embarrassment of riches, with a truly talented cast.
However, its dismal box office performance is a powerful reminder that just because a movie is filled with big-name stars doesn’t mean it’s going to do well or succeed in attracting a large audience. Reddit users, always tuned into the world of popular culture, have also made their opinions very clear on some of the worst star-studded movies to emerge over the years.
Movie 43 (2013)
Stream on Hulu
Movie 43 is one of those movies that has come to be considered one of the worst ever made. There are many reasons for this, but it’s certainly not helped by the fact that he has far too many storylines and never really masters any of them.
Hunterlong12 says, “I saw a movie 43 in the cinema and it was hilarious. Half of the actors looked really uncomfortable being there. I was one of three people there. The visible discomfort of the actors involved in the production makes it very difficult for even the friendliest member of the audience to lose themselves in the fiction.
The Bonfire of the Vanities (1990)
Stream to Prime Video
At first glance, it must have seemed that the dark comedy satire The bonfire of vanities would make a good successful movie, as it starred Bruce Willis, Tom Hanks and Melanie Griffith. Unfortunately, it was ravaged by critics, who objected to the casting, among other things.
Reddit users identified it as one of the worst starred movies, with Positive-Source8205 saying, “It was a shitty book too.” This is definitely one of those times when the essential features of a book are stripped down in translation from page to page.
The Counselor (2013)
Stream on HBO Max
Ridley Scott is one of Hollywood’s most famous directors. However, even he is not immune to the problem of a few bad movies, and The counselor is, in the eyes of many Redditors, one of his worst. As byfuryattheheart says, “I came here to say The Counsellor. Incredibly bad shot with an incredibly amazing cast lol. I can never forget the Diaz windshield scene.
It’s one of Scott’s films that is notably lacking, in that it relies far too heavily on its (very talented) cast, without the backing of a good script or inspired direction, both necessary to make a strong thriller.
The Dead Don’t Die (2019)
Stream to Prime Video
The dead don’t die is, on paper, one of those films that should succeed. After all, comedy-horror is generally a reliable source of income for Hollywood, and it has a very solid cast, including Bill Murray, Adam Driver and Tilda Swinton. Many Redditors are particularly scathing about this film, with many being particularly critical of the casting.
ELB2001 puts it this way: “It’s as if they were told to act like robots.” The deadpan delivery of Driver and Murray in particular is often at odds with the comedy the film manages to evoke.
Don’t Look Up (2021)
Stream on Netflix
Don’t look up turned out to be a remarkably divisive film. Despite his very talented cast – which includes, among others, Meryl Streep and Leonardo DiCaprio – he has been ridiculed for being, among other things, a little too enamored with his own intelligence.
Plus, as Karsvolcanospace puts it, “And so many roles just didn’t need big names either. Most of the characters outside of Lawrence and DiCaprio were just ‘hurr durr I’m stupid what the hell you said,” so I don’t know why they needed people like Meryl Streep for that. In the end, the very thing that should have guaranteed her success ultimately contributed to many people’s dislike of her. Sometimes even a star-studded cast isn’t enough to save a film from excess.
Stream to YouTube
Hollywood history is filled with notable and beloved examples of great musicals. Unfortunately, despite all this stage success, the film version of Cats was badly born. Even its extraordinary cast — which included the likes of Judi Dench and Ian McKellen — wasn’t enough to save it from terrible CGI and a lackluster script.
Mojito_sangria had this to say, “All the movie versions of Cats are a bit underwhelming, the play just isn’t made for the screen.” It’s good advice that the filmmakers should have taken to heart, because the film’s bitter failure with critics and audiences has done a lot of damage to the play’s reputation.
Valentine’s Day (2010)
Stream on Prime Video
Valentine’s day is a very fine film of its time. With several interconnecting stories tied together by the title party, it has both a highly skilled cast and a talented director in Garry Marshall. However, it’s precisely the abundance that makes him feel a bit too frantic for his own good.
WEEGEMAN says bluntly, “I’m glad Valentine’s Day is on the list. Horrible movie. It’s the kind of movie that would have done well to remember that sometimes it’s true that less is more, and that just having multiple stars in the same movie can’t hold together a sprawling movie. .
Pearl Harbor (2001)
Stream to YouTube
Hollywood produced many great war and military films, and at the time it must have seemed wearing pearls would be one of them. It features a very solid cast of successful young stars, including Ben Affleck, Josh Harnett and Kate Beckinsale. Unfortunately, even they were not enough to save him from the melodramatic and mundane excesses of his own plot.
Ok_comparison_8304 scathingly writes, “The love triangle between Affleck, Beckinsdale, and Hartnett has to remain one of the most corny and gruesome story arcs I’ve been subjected to.” The fact that it’s directed by Michael Bay, a director little known for his restraint in his filmmaking, only makes its excesses all the more glaring.
Monument Men (2014)
Stream on Starz
In George Clooney’s best movies, he has shown time and time again why he is one of the industry’s most respected talents. He also turned to directing and The men of the monuments brings in a number of talented cast members, including Bill Murray, John Goodman, and Matt Damon.
Karsvolcanoscape, however, found the film disappointing, writing that it is “just the epitome of a decent movie”. Considering the talent that went into making this film, this is a particularly harrowing result.
Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1978)
Stream to Prime Video
Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band is, without a doubt, a truly strange film. It’s a weird mix of jukebox musical comedy, and it stars Peter Frampton and the Bee Gees, both of whom were hugely popular when it was released.
Despite its lofty ambitions, it quickly becomes little more than a variety show, with no governing cinematic logic to help bring the musical numbers together. So it’s no wonder Redditor toddfredd calls it “a crime against humanity.” The film reminds musicians around the world that sometimes it’s best to leave the acting role to others.
NEXT: 10 Most Disappointing Horror Movie Endings, According To Reddit